2 — Distinguishing Levels of Claim

Critical Thinking and Epistemology · 5:50

Listen on 93

Lyrics

[Verse 1]
When the news breaks and the stories fly
Different claims at different heights
Some might be true, some might be lies
You gotta learn to size them right
Like a trader with their money on the line
Match your confidence to what you find

[Chorus]
Strong claims need strong proof to stand
Weak claims need just a gentle hand
Size your conviction like you trade
Don't bet more than the evidence made
Level one, level two, level three
Match your certainty to what you see

[Verse 2]
"There's organization behind this crowd"
That's level one, it's quite allowed
Most big protests have support and plans
Logistics, funding, helping hands
This claim is reasonable, probably true
Standard evidence will see you through

[Chorus]
Strong claims need strong proof to stand
Weak claims need just a gentle hand
Size your conviction like you trade
Don't bet more than the evidence made
Level one, level two, level three
Match your certainty to what you see

[Verse 3]
"The protesters are being bused in here"
Now that's level two, be more severe
Specific, falsifiable, needs more proof
Bus schedules, photos, something bulletproof
A stronger claim requires stronger backing
Without it, credibility you're lacking

[Bridge]
"The whole thing is a con, it's all fake"
Level three's the strongest claim you make
Extraordinary evidence you need
For extraordinary claims indeed
Like betting everything on one sure trade
Make sure your homework has been made

[Chorus]
Strong claims need strong proof to stand
Weak claims need just a gentle hand
Size your conviction like you trade
Don't bet more than the evidence made
Level one, level two, level three
Match your certainty to what you see

[Outro]
Be the analyst who gets it right
Calibrate your claims with all your might
From gentle doubts to certain facts
Size your statements, check your facts

← 1 — Holding Multiple Hypotheses | 3 — The Trader's Real Edge →