Credible Commitment and Its Critics

Truncus Arteriosus: Cardiac Pathology and Surgery · 3:34

Listen on 93

Lyrics

[Verse 1]
Sixteen eighty-eight, the Crown signs away its claim,
Parliament holds the purse now, nothing's quite the same,
North and Weingast wrote it down, a tidy little tale,
Constrain the king, the lenders trust, and interest rates derail—
downward, that's the thesis, credible as stone,
a monarch bound by statute isn't ruling all alone,
creditors exhale, they figure risk is low,
lend your gold to Whitehall, watch the Treasury grow

[Chorus]
Commitment, commitment, lock the royal hand,
Glorious Revolution writes the credit of the land,
But trust ain't automatic, don't take it on a hunch—
check the yields, check the years, before you swallow lunch
Commitment, commitment, that's the mnemonic cue:
Bind the king, bonds get cheap—but is that really true?

[Verse 2]
Sussman and Yafeh pull the ledgers off the shelf,
decades roll by, interest rates don't drop down by themselves,
high for years past eighty-eight, the timeline doesn't fit,
if the settlement's the hero, why's the premium still lit?
Stasavage counters with a sharper, partisan design:
it's not the walls of Parliament, it's Whigs along the line,
a creditor coalition sitting cozy in the House,
guarding their own bonds like a cat protects a mouse

[Chorus]
Commitment, commitment, lock the royal hand,
Glorious Revolution writes the credit of the land,
But trust ain't automatic, don't take it on a hunch—
check the yields, check the years, before you swallow lunch
Commitment, commitment, that's the mnemonic cue:
Bind the king, bonds get cheap—but is that really true?

[Verse 3]
Pincus and Robinson say forget the quiet frame,
sixteen eighty-eight was fire, not a gentleman's game,
a political-economy shake that rattled every wall,
revolution with a ledger, not a peaceful tea-time call,
meanwhile Brewer's looking elsewhere, not at oaths or pacts,
he's counting excise men with ink-stained fingers, clipboards, facts,
the Sinews of Power, he says, were bureaucrats who'd tax,
a fiscal-military state built on stamps and wax

[Bridge]
So was it trust, or was it Whigs, or muscle in the clerks?
The Stop of the Exchequer shows how fast a promise shirks,
the Bank of England rises where the royal word once broke,
and Hamilton in Philadelphia hears the echo when he spoke

[Chorus]
Commitment, commitment, lock the royal hand,
Glorious Revolution writes the credit of the land,
But trust ain't automatic, don't take it on a hunch—
check the yields, check the years, before you swallow lunch
Commitment, commitment, that's the mnemonic cue:
Bind the king, bonds get cheap—but is that really true?

[Outro]
Institutions, coalitions, clerks who count the till,
every fiscal state's a puzzle creditors must fill,
remember North and Weingast, remember who said no—
that's the sound of credit forming, centuries ago

← The Debtor State's Menu | Dissolution of the Monasteries →