The HR System Broken
13 chapters
1. 4 — The Measurement Trap
[Verse 1]
HR counts the things they see
Training hours, one two three
But did you learn? They'll never know
Just check the box and off you go
Time to fill positions fast
But will this hire really last?
They measure speed, not quality
Missing what we really need
[Chorus]
It's the measurement trap, snap snap snap
Count what's easy, miss the gap
Between the numbers on the screen
And what those numbers really mean
Goodhart's Law will catch you flat
When targets make the measures crack
It's the measurement trap, snap snap snap
HR's stuck inside that gap
[Verse 2]
Policies stack up high and wide
But do employees trust their guide?
Reviews completed, check them all
But performance didn't rise or fall
Diversity by percentage shown
But do all voices find their home?
The spreadsheet says we're doing well
But culture's got a different tale
[Chorus]
It's the measurement trap, snap snap snap
Count what's easy, miss the gap
Between the numbers on the screen
And what those numbers really mean
Goodhart's Law will catch you flat
When targets make the measures crack
It's the measurement trap, snap snap snap
HR's stuck inside that gap
[Bridge]
Survey scores go up each year
But engagement's insincere
Turnover's down, they celebrate
Not knowing if they kept the great
Or lost the stars while keeping dead weight
Finance wants numbers they can see
So HR measures desperately
What can be counted, not what's true
Missing the whole purpose through
[Verse 3]
Trust and culture can't be weighed
Development's not a simple grade
The gap between what matters most
And metrics HR loves to post
Gets wider every single day
While real success just fades away
They lack the skills to measure right
And keep the true goals out of sight
[Final Chorus]
It's the measurement trap, snap snap snap
Count what's easy, miss the gap
When measures become the target aim
They lose their value in the game
The core outputs are hard to track
But proxy metrics lead off track
It's the measurement trap, snap snap snap
Time to bridge that deadly gap
[Outro]
Don't measure just what you can see
Measure what you need to be
The trap is set, but you can flee
If you choose quality over quantity
2. 3 — The Compliance Theater Failure
[Verse 1]
They hand you a binder, two hundred pages thick
Policies for everything, from parking to your pic
Anti-harassment training, click through every slide
But when the real problems come, there's nowhere left to hide
[Chorus]
It's compliance theater, just for show
Training doesn't make the bad stuff go
Document and check the box today
But the behaviors never change that way
Compliance theater, legal shield
Protection for the company's revealed
Not for you, just for their defense
When the lawsuits commence
[Verse 2]
Diversity training's mandatory, sit there for an hour
But Harvard's research shows it backfires with its power
Psychological reactance kicks in when you're told what to think
Black women lose positions while the metrics start to sink
[Chorus]
It's compliance theater, just for show
Training doesn't make the bad stuff go
Document and check the box today
But the behaviors never change that way
Compliance theater, legal shield
Protection for the company's revealed
Not for you, just for their defense
When the lawsuits commence
[Bridge]
Meta-analyses prove what we suspected all along
Completion rates are high but retention's pretty wrong
When policies pile up like snow, contempt begins to grow
Important rules get lost inside the bureaucratic show
[Verse 3]
Write it down, document it all, create that paper trail
Performance issues, discipline, accommodation's tale
It's honest when they tell you it's just risk management
But don't pretend this theater serves the employee's benefit
[Chorus]
It's compliance theater, just for show
Training doesn't make the bad stuff go
Document and check the box today
But the behaviors never change that way
Compliance theater, legal shield
Protection for the company's revealed
Not for you, just for their defense
When the lawsuits commence
[Outro]
The curtain falls on policies
That nobody believes
Compliance theater's final bow
While real change never breathes
3. 4 — The Employee Experience Failure
[Verse 1]
Welcome to your first day here, got a stack of forms to sign
Benefits and policies, you'll be reading through till nine
They call it onboarding but you're processed like a case
While the real culture waits behind a bureaucratic face
No one tells you who to know or how things really flow
Just compliance boxes checked before they let you go
[Chorus]
It's the employee experience failure, dressed up but hollow inside
Surveys that lie, programs that hide
What workers need to truly thrive
Compliance masquerading, engagement that's fake
HR solutions for management's sake
The experience breaks
[Verse 2]
Survey time comes around again, they want to know your thoughts
But your manager sees the scores and you know you could get caught
So you answer what sounds right, not what's burning in your chest
'Cause honesty might cost you when they're grading your request
The numbers look good on the chart but the truth stays underground
Social desirability is the only honest sound
[Chorus]
It's the employee experience failure, dressed up but hollow inside
Surveys that lie, programs that hide
What workers need to truly thrive
Compliance masquerading, engagement that's fake
HR solutions for management's sake
The experience breaks
[Bridge]
Recognition platforms ping while bad managers reign
Wellness apps and team building can't heal the deeper pain
What we need is simple but it's harder than it seems
Good direction, real feedback, and care that's not just dreams
[Verse 3]
Exit interviews reveal the same old story every year
Bad boss, no growth, the pay, the stress that brought you here
They collect the data points but nothing ever shifts
'Cause systemic problems need authority that lifts
Above what HR controls, to the C-suite where change lives
But the cycle just repeats with each goodbye that gives
[Chorus]
It's the employee experience failure, dressed up but hollow inside
Surveys that lie, programs that hide
What workers need to truly thrive
Compliance masquerading, engagement that's fake
HR solutions for management's sake
The experience breaks
[Outro]
Processing not welcoming, measuring not truth
Programs not real management, exit without proof
The employee experience needs more than HR can make
Real change comes from the top, for everyone's sake
4. 1 — The Hiring Failure
[Verse 1]
Sarah's got the skills to code and lead the team
Ten years building apps, she lives the coding dream
But the ATS machine just scanned her resume
No bachelor's degree, so it throws her away
The system's looking for the perfect paper trail
While real talent gets lost in the automated fail
[Chorus]
HR's hiring failure, screening out the best
Seventy-five percent rejected, never pass the test
Keywords over capability, boxes over brains
The hiring paradigm is broken, talented people pay the pain
Fiction in job descriptions, interviews that lie
Culture fit means just like us, diversity denied
[Verse 2]
Job description says you need a PhD
For a role that's really just basic HTML and CSS
Written by HR who's never touched the code
Approved by managers from a different episode
Five to seven years required, bachelor's preferred
But the actual daily work? That's never heard
[Chorus]
HR's hiring failure, screening out the best
Seventy-five percent rejected, never pass the test
Keywords over capability, boxes over brains
The hiring paradigm is broken, talented people pay the pain
Fiction in job descriptions, interviews that lie
Culture fit means just like us, diversity denied
[Bridge]
Tell me about a time when you overcame
But introverts can't play the interview game
Hidden workers by the millions cast aside
While mediocre resumes get to take the ride
Harvard studied, documented what we know
Quality candidates have nowhere to go
[Verse 3]
Structured questions test your storytelling skill
Not whether you can code or lead with will
Culture fit screening sounds so nice and clean
But it's bias with a process in between
The timeline takes so long the good ones leave
While the desperate and available we receive
[Chorus]
HR's hiring failure, screening out the best
Seventy-five percent rejected, never pass the test
Keywords over capability, boxes over brains
The hiring paradigm is broken, talented people pay the pain
Fiction in job descriptions, interviews that lie
Culture fit means just like us, diversity denied
[Outro]
Industrial scale rejection of the qualified
Automated screening leaves the talent denied
The system's optimizing for the wrong thing
Real performance lost in the process ring
5. 5 — The Compensation Failure
[Verse 1]
They say they keep salaries private for you
To protect your privacy, that's what they do
But when no one knows what their neighbor makes
The house always wins, whatever it takes
Information is power, they hold all the cards
While you're left guessing, playing blind in the yard
[Chorus]
Opacity, negotiation, audit without action, benchmarking to the middle
Compensation failure's got us trapped inside this riddle
They design the game so they always win the prize
While equity and fairness slowly die before our eyes
Opacity, negotiation, audit without action, benchmarking to the middle
That's the compensation riddle
[Verse 2]
Starting salary depends on how well you fight
But some folks were taught that pushing isn't right
Women face backlash when they ask for more
Minorities struggle to even the score
HR knows the research, sees the bias clear
But keeps using negotiation year after year
[Chorus]
Opacity, negotiation, audit without action, benchmarking to the middle
Compensation failure's got us trapped inside this riddle
They design the game so they always win the prize
While equity and fairness slowly die before our eyes
Opacity, negotiation, audit without action, benchmarking to the middle
That's the compensation riddle
[Bridge]
Pay equity audits sound so nice and fair
But they compare apples to apples with mathematical care
Missing all the structure that keeps some people down
Women in low-paid roles, minorities not around
And when they find disparities, what do they do?
Fix the worst cases, ignore the rest of you
[Verse 3]
Market benchmarking to find the median rate
Everyone's aiming for that same baseline fate
When all companies target the middle ground
True differentiation can't be found
It's a race to average, a ceiling disguised
As competitive wisdom, but it's really comprised
[Final Chorus]
Opacity, negotiation, audit without action, benchmarking to the middle
Compensation failure's got us trapped inside this riddle
The paradigm's broken but they claim it's working fine
While real equity gets left behind
Opacity, negotiation, audit without action, benchmarking to the middle
That's the compensation riddle
That's the compensation riddle
6. 6 — The Diversity and Inclusion Failure
[Verse 1]
They hired diverse faces for the company floor
But the boardroom still looks like it did before
Pattern matching promotions, same old crew
Entry level rainbow, but the top stays blue
Culture fit they're calling it, but what's the cost
When different voices in translation get lost
[Chorus]
Decoration not transformation
Programs without penetration
Check the box and walk away
DEI's just for display
Numbers lie when hearts don't change
Diversity in name only remains
[Verse 2]
Mandatory training in the conference room
Everyone's there but they're filled with gloom
Dobbin and Kalev tracked it for thirty years
Forced education just increases fears
Eight hundred companies, the data's clear
Voluntary beats mandatory, year after year
[Chorus]
Decoration not transformation
Programs without penetration
Check the box and walk away
DEI's just for display
Numbers lie when hearts don't change
Diversity in name only remains
[Bridge]
When HR owns it, business walks away
"That's not my job," is what the leaders say
Siloed solutions never scale or stick
Line leaders owning it, that's the trick
Mentoring matters, task forces too
Diversity managers see it through
[Verse 3]
Fifty percent women in management roles
But listen closer to their untold stories' tolls
Excluded from networks where the real deals flow
Dismissed in meetings, their ideas don't grow
Representation metrics paint a pretty scene
But belonging failures hide behind the screen
[Chorus]
Decoration not transformation
Programs without penetration
Check the box and walk away
DEI's just for display
Numbers lie when hearts don't change
Diversity in name only remains
[Outro]
Count the faces, miss the hearts
That's where real inclusion starts
Structural change beats surface show
That's how equity can grow
7. 1 — Institutional Inertia
[Verse 1]
In every office tower, in every corporate hall
HR departments standing, ten stories tall
Degrees and certifications line the wall
SHRM and HRCI badges for them all
Built their lives around this paradigm
Now change feels like corporate crime
[Chorus]
Institutional inertia, spinning round and round
Too big to pivot, too deep in the ground
Conferences and consultants, keeping status quo
When your career depends on it, you're afraid to let it go
Inertia, inertia, the weight of what we know
Makes it hard to change the way the people business grows
[Verse 2]
Professional associations host their yearly shows
Thousands gather to discuss the way it goes
Consulting firms sell solutions, same old prose
Academic programs teaching what everyone knows
Economic engine running on the past
Makes transformation happen very last
[Chorus]
Institutional inertia, spinning round and round
Too big to pivot, too deep in the ground
Conferences and consultants, keeping status quo
When your career depends on it, you're afraid to let it go
Inertia, inertia, the weight of what we know
Makes it hard to change the way the people business grows
[Bridge]
Self-sustaining ecosystem
Feeds itself and keeps the rhythm
Threatening the infrastructure
Means threatening every future
Built on old foundations
[Verse 3]
When tens of thousands have invested years
In mastery of systems, facing all their fears
Change means their expertise just disappears
The social cost of progress brings them tears
So round and round the wheel will always turn
Until the burning platforms force us all to learn
[Chorus]
Institutional inertia, spinning round and round
Too big to pivot, too deep in the ground
Conferences and consultants, keeping status quo
When your career depends on it, you're afraid to let it go
Inertia, inertia, the weight of what we know
Makes it hard to change the way the people business grows
[Outro]
The paradigm persists because
The paradigm persists because
The paradigm persists because
That's how inertia works
8. 7 — The Technology Failure
[Verse 1]
They promised us efficiency, a digital solution
HR systems everywhere, the tech revolution
But when you automate broken, you get broken that's fast
Same old biased processes, now they're built to last
[Chorus]
Fast and broken, surveillance and lies
Algorithmic bias in corporate disguise
Vendor capture, data that spies
Technology failure before our eyes
Fast and broken, that's the paradigm
When HR tech crosses every line
[Verse 2]
Amazon's AI learned to hate the word "women's"
Penalized every resume, bias never ends
Machine learning on old data brings the past alive
Historical discrimination, now it's automated drive
[Chorus]
Fast and broken, surveillance and lies
Algorithmic bias in corporate disguise
Vendor capture, data that spies
Technology failure before our eyes
Fast and broken, that's the paradigm
When HR tech crosses every line
[Bridge]
They're watching every keystroke, reading every mail
Sentiment analysis, productivity trail
People analytics sounds so scientific
But it's just surveillance, systematic and specific
[Verse 3]
Workday, SAP, Oracle lock you in tight
Switching costs so high, you lose the fight
Your processes bend to fit their mold
Platform dictates everything, your freedom's sold
[Chorus]
Fast and broken, surveillance and lies
Algorithmic bias in corporate disguise
Vendor capture, data that spies
Technology failure before our eyes
Fast and broken, that's the paradigm
When HR tech crosses every line
[Outro]
Don't digitize the broken
Don't automate the wrong
True transformation means redesign
Not just a faster song
Fast and broken won't set us free
Technology failure, can't you see?
9. 2 — Fear-Based Decision Making
[Verse 1]
When the boardroom gets nervous and voices run high
They ask what could happen if HR should die
Lawsuits and scandals dance in their heads
While better solutions stay safely unread
The devil you know feels safer than change
Even when results are clearly quite strange
[Chorus]
Fear-based decisions keep us locked in place
What if we fail becomes the only case
The downside's vivid, the upside's unclear
So we choose the broken path that we know and fear
Status quo wins when we're scared to fall
Fear-based thinking is the trap of all
[Verse 2]
They paint us pictures of courtroom despair
Compliance disasters hanging in air
Public relations nightmares so real
While innovation gets no chance to heal
The concrete threat beats the abstract gain
So outdated systems forever remain
[Chorus]
Fear-based decisions keep us locked in place
What if we fail becomes the only case
The downside's vivid, the upside's unclear
So we choose the broken path that we know and fear
Status quo wins when we're scared to fall
Fear-based thinking is the trap of all
[Bridge]
Better hiring's just a distant dream
Higher engagement's not part of the scheme
Faster adaptation sounds nice in theory
But risk aversion keeps our vision bleary
Loss-averse minds will choose the devil they know
Even when the evidence screams let it go
[Chorus]
Fear-based decisions keep us locked in place
What if we fail becomes the only case
The downside's vivid, the upside's unclear
So we choose the broken path that we know and fear
Status quo wins when we're scared to fall
Fear-based thinking is the trap of all
[Outro]
When fear decides, progress dies
The future waits while fear still flies
Break the cycle, face the unknown
Let better systems find their home
10. 3 — Executive Convenience
[Verse 1]
When employees come with problems at the door
Executives don't handle them anymore
There's a department that will take the heat
A buffer zone that keeps their hands clean and neat
They say "go talk to HR about your pay"
"That's not my call" is what they always say
[Chorus]
It's executive convenience, don't you see
A perfect shield from responsibility
Buffer, scapegoat, compliance too
Process layer that they can hide behind and use
Executive convenience, oh so neat
Makes the tough decisions someone else's beat
[Verse 2]
When layoffs come and people lose their jobs
The leaders point to HR and just shrug their shoulders
"We wanted to keep you but our hands were tied"
"The HR department made us say goodbye"
A scapegoat ready when the choice goes wrong
They never have to face the angry throng
[Chorus]
It's executive convenience, don't you see
A perfect shield from responsibility
Buffer, scapegoat, compliance too
Process layer that they can hide behind and use
Executive convenience, oh so neat
Makes the tough decisions someone else's beat
[Bridge]
Legal issues? "HR handles that domain"
Performance problems? "Not my job to explain"
They've built a wall between themselves and staff
While HR takes the heat and leadership can laugh
Dismantling this would mean they'd have to own
Every people choice from their executive throne
[Verse 3]
The process infrastructure's in place
So leaders never have to show their face
When hard decisions about people arise
They've got a department full of alibis
Direct responsibility they'd rather avoid
That's why this broken system stays employed
[Chorus]
It's executive convenience, don't you see
A perfect shield from responsibility
Buffer, scapegoat, compliance too
Process layer that they can hide behind and use
Executive convenience, oh so neat
Makes the tough decisions someone else's beat
[Outro]
Until leaders own the people that they lead
HR convenience is all they'll ever need
11. 4 — The Legal-Industrial Complex
[Verse 1]
There's a system built around the HR machine
Lawyers, vendors, consultants keeping it running clean
Employment law firms billing by the hour
HR tech companies selling compliance power
Training vendors promising to reduce your risk
It's a billion-dollar ecosystem, hard to dismiss
[Chorus]
It's the legal-industrial complex at play
More policies, more training every day
They profit when HR stays the same old way
Compliance and risk is what they always say
The legal-industrial complex at play
Keeping broken systems here to stay
[Verse 2]
Every workplace issue needs another solution
More software, more workshops, more contribution
Consultants recommend what they're selling next
Another policy manual, another training text
The narrative of danger keeps the money flowing
While real workplace problems keep on growing
[Chorus]
It's the legal-industrial complex at play
More policies, more training every day
They profit when HR stays the same old way
Compliance and risk is what they always say
The legal-industrial complex at play
Keeping broken systems here to stay
[Bridge]
When your revenue depends on the status quo
You're not incentivized to let it go
More process, more meetings, more bureaucracy
That's how they maintain their dependency
The answer's always buy what they're selling
While workplace culture keeps rebelling
[Verse 3]
HR budgets justified by fear and regulation
Feeding an entire industry across the nation
Every vendor has a stake in keeping things complex
'Cause simple solutions don't generate their checks
The paradigm persists 'cause too much depends on it
A self-reinforcing cycle, hard to quit
[Chorus]
It's the legal-industrial complex at play
More policies, more training every day
They profit when HR stays the same old way
Compliance and risk is what they always say
The legal-industrial complex at play
Keeping broken systems here to stay
[Outro]
Follow the money, see who benefits most
From keeping HR as a bureaucratic host
The legal-industrial complex at play
That's why real change gets pushed away
12. 1 — HR Is Built on an Impossible Promise
[Verse 1]
There's a department that claims to serve us all
Says they'll protect both worker and the company hall
But when push comes to shove and the lines get blurred
They're paid by one side, their loyalty's assured
[Chorus]
Impossible promise, can't serve two masters
One paycheck flowing, who do you think they're after
Protect the business, advocate for you
Legal compliance and strategic moves too
Impossible promise, it's designed to fail
Can't be the referee when you're not impartial
[Verse 2]
When harassment claims hit the top sales star
Do they choose justice or protect revenue by far
When compliance needs documentation slow
But strategy demands they move fast and go
[Chorus]
Impossible promise, can't serve two masters
One paycheck flowing, who do you think they're after
Protect the business, advocate for you
Legal compliance and strategic moves too
Impossible promise, it's designed to fail
Can't be the referee when you're not impartial
[Bridge]
Lawyers don't represent both plaintiff and defense
Auditors can't audit their own expense
Referees don't suit up for either team
But HR claims neutrality in this broken scheme
[Verse 3]
It's not the people, it's the paradigm
A structural flaw built into the design
Five different masters pulling different ways
No wonder trust erodes with every passing day
[Chorus]
Impossible promise, can't serve two masters
One paycheck flowing, who do you think they're after
Protect the business, advocate for you
Legal compliance and strategic moves too
Impossible promise, it's designed to fail
Can't be the referee when you're not impartial
[Outro]
When conflict of interest is baked right in
The impossible promise can never win
The system's broken by its own design
Time to draw a clearer line
13. The Core Problem: One Department, Conflicting Masters
[Verse 1]
There's a department in the middle of it all
Claims to serve everyone when conflicts call
Employee grievances on the left side of their desk
Management directives on the right causing stress
Two different masters with opposing needs
How can one team serve when loyalty bleeds
[Chorus]
Split allegiance, torn in two
Can't serve both when interests grew
Apart from each other's goals
HR's caught between the roles
Two masters calling out their name
But only one can win this game
Split allegiance, that's the core
Of why this system fails for sure
[Verse 2]
When workers need protection from unfair demands
HR listens closely with their caring hands
But when the budget calls for layoffs next week
Those same hands must decide who hits the peak
Of the termination list they're building now
The trust is broken, they don't know quite how
[Chorus]
Split allegiance, torn in two
Can't serve both when interests grew
Apart from each other's goals
HR's caught between the roles
Two masters calling out their name
But only one can win this game
Split allegiance, that's the core
Of why this system fails for sure
[Bridge]
Who signs the paychecks in the end
Determines where loyalties bend
The workers think they have a friend
But corporate needs will always win
It's not malicious, it's design
Built into every single line
Of how this broken system works
[Verse 3]
The salary negotiations hit the floor
Employee wants more, company wants less and more
Control over the terms of the deal they make
HR sits between them for both parties' sake
But when push comes to shove and decisions are made
Guess which side gets the better trade
[Chorus]
Split allegiance, torn in two
Can't serve both when interests grew
Apart from each other's goals
HR's caught between the roles
Two masters calling out their name
But only one can win this game
Split allegiance, that's the core
Of why this system fails for sure
[Outro]
One department, conflicting masters
Recipe for workplace disasters
Until we fix this core design
The failures will continue down the line
Back to Home