The influential reframing (Goodale and Milner, 1992): "what" vs "how"

hip hop dubstep, breakstep samba · 4:19

Listen on 93

Lyrics

[Verse 1]
Back in ninety-two, Goodale and Milner saw
Two streams of vision with a different call
Not just "where" and "what" like we thought before
But "how" and "what" - they opened up the door
Dorsal stream computes for action's need
Ventral builds the world that we perceive

[Chorus]
What versus how, the brain divides the load
Vision for perception down the ventral road
Vision for action takes the dorsal way
Two separate systems working night and day
What versus how, remember this refrain
Double dissociation proves they're not the same

[Verse 2]
Meet patient D.F., carbon monoxide's curse
Damaged ventral stream, but here's what's perverse
She cannot tell you if a slot runs straight
Or recognize the size upon her plate
But watch her hand move with perfect grace
Threading cards through slots she cannot trace

[Chorus]
What versus how, the brain divides the load
Vision for perception down the ventral road
Vision for action takes the dorsal way
Two separate systems working night and day
What versus how, remember this refrain
Double dissociation proves they're not the same

[Verse 3]
Optic ataxia tells the flip side tale
Parietal damage makes their reaching fail
They'll name each object, know it crystal clear
But grasp for coffee cups that aren't quite there
Perception's perfect, action goes astray
When dorsal pathways lose their guiding way

[Verse 4]
Temporal cortex for the what we know
Parietal lobe for how our actions flow
Online control versus conscious sight
One works in darkness, one needs the light
Evolution's answer to survive and thrive
Keep these systems functionally alive

[Bridge]
Egocentric coordinates for grasping motion
Allocentric maps for recognition's potion
Real-time guidance versus memory's store
Two parallel worlds behind perception's door
Cleanest evidence that neuroscience has found
Functional separation, safe and sound

[Chorus]
What versus how, the brain divides the load
Vision for perception down the ventral road
Vision for action takes the dorsal way
Two separate systems working night and day
What versus how, remember this refrain
Double dissociation proves they're not the same

[Outro]
So when you reach out for your morning brew
Remember streams of vision, split in two
Goodale and Milner showed us something true
The brain's not one, but systems numbering two

← The original formulation (Ungerleider and Mishkin, 1982): "what" vs "where" | The caveats you must keep →